US Association of Martial Arts
Zen Beikoku Bujutsu Kyokai
                 全米国武術協会
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Vision & Mission
    • Board of Directors
  • Services
    • Training Seminars
  • Join USAMA
    • Individual Membership
    • School Accreditation
  • Blog

USAMA BLOG

Raising the standards of the martial arts

READ BELOW

What Does It Mean To Be Legitimate?

9/16/2016

3 Comments

 
Author: Bret Gordon
Picture
After only being published for a few hours, my previous article on Taekwondo (read it here) caused a great discussion on my Facebook page and has brought up an interesting question. What does it mean to be legitimate?

Let me start off by saying that everything in this article is my personal opinion. If you have a different opinion, I'd love to hear about it in the comments below. The whole purpose of this blog is create discussion and share information.

When discussing legitimacy, there are several factors to take into account. Immediately, if your system is governed by a specific organization then they are the sole providers of legitimacy. For example, my art is governed my the International San Budo Federation. Anyone claiming to hold rank in or teach San Budo Sogo Bugei and is not affiliated with the ISBF is illegitimate and fraudulent. So if your art has a similar organization, then the answer is simple. But what if that's not the case. What if there are multiple governing bodies for your art, or even none? 


Picture
Prior to the establishment of large martial arts organizations, legitimacy was determined by your performance. It didn't matter who you learned from, if you could hold your own you earned respect. This is how many of the pioneers made a name for themselves and started their own systems. No one would think to question Miyagi Chojun's fighting ability, and Kodokan Judo was essentially established through competitions against other jujutsu systems. Karl Marx is a great example of this. With no prior martial arts experience, he challenged and beat everyone on his local karate circuit, eventually establishing his own system called Keichu Do (The Cajun Way). No one questioned his teaching ability or the quality of his students, and he eventually did earn legitimate credentials from numerous prestigious organizations, including the All Japan Karate-Do Federation. But was he illegitimate before earning that paperwork? I guess that determines how you define legitimacy.

I think there are different kinds of legitimacy, and it all comes down to what you claim. All of those pioneers issued certification to their students and now in today's society, we have access to legitimate organizations which are widely recognized as the leaders in their respective fields. Therefore, it only makes sense to be affiliated with them and fall under their umbrella. But who determines if those organizations are legitimate? In the case of the Kukkiwon, their authorization comes directly from the government of Korea. In Japan, there are several government recognized organizations. But to me, the lineage of those in charge of the organization is what makes it legitimate. If I was looking to join a multi-style organization, even if I practice a different art than its directors, if they have solid credentials then I'd want to be affiliated with them. After all, your certification is only as valuable as the respect you have for the person signing it.

So the question is can someone with little to no formal instruction open a martial arts school, become a pillar of their community and provide quality instruction? Yes they can. It has been proven by Grandmaster Marx. But to me, being a quality martial artist and a legitimate instructor are 2 different things. No matter how good he was, once he received proper licensing is when he became a legitimate founder and instructor. There are plenty of great fighters out there, especially in the MMA community, who could wipe the floor with most traditional martial artists. But that doesn't make them a more legitimate martial artist. What separates us from the fighters are our traditions, our values and our lineages (certification being proof of our lineage).

Certification is important. Having a paper trail ensures a direct line of transmission, in theory, to the origin of our respective systems. In the medical field, no matter how skilled someone is, if they do not have proper licensing then they cannot practice medicine or risk being jailed. You cannot teach at a public school without first obtaining a degree in Education. Of course, no one is going to jail in the US for teaching martial arts without proper certification, but the premise is still valid. We don't even let barbers or cosmetologists cut our hair without proper licensing, so why should martial arts be any different? It doesn't matter how skilled you are, in today's society your credentials can protect you from questions about your legitimacy.

So what happens if you don't have proper credentials? There are numerous organizations out there, including the US Association of Martial Arts, which can help you obtain them. In the real world, your assailant is not going to back away if you have a prestigious certificate. You must have the skill to back it up. But that being said, if you are claiming to be an instructor, a master or a founder, you must have the paperwork to back up your claims. It's not enough to be good on the mat. You may be a great practitioner, or even a great instructor. But you're still illegitimate.

3 Comments
Bret Gordon
9/17/2016 10:06:32 am

When I say legitimacy is determined by what you claim, let me clarify. If you are simply claiming to be the best martial artist or highest quality school in your area, the proof is on the mat. If you are claiming any sort of rank or title, you need valid paperwork to back it up.

Reply
Martin Pedat
10/16/2016 11:26:32 am

I look at legitimacy from a different perspective. I believe it stems from the quality of the techniques; that is, the effectiveness of the techniques in the system as applied in the real word. Organizations and instructors give out belt rank but you know Bret that such an accomplishment doesn't mean that the person, system or rank is legitimate. Just go to any karate tournament in America to prove my point. My instructor once told me the following profound statement: an organization, sanctioning body and/or instructor can take my rent or belt away but let's go into the back room and see who comes out a live. Legitimacy comes over a period of time where the system in proven in the field of combat. Many recognized martial arts today have lost their relevance and legitimacy because they failed to adapt. So, I don't care who you trained with or whether your art can be traced back to "Adam and Eve". What matters to me is that the techniques and philosophy can save my and my family's life in the streets. I know that is sacrilegious but remember the source. None of my martial arts have long traditions. By the way, no disrespect is intended to anyone in making these comments. It's my humble opinion and I do respect those who follow and teach the traditions.

Reply
NinjaMan
10/17/2016 11:24:54 am

My only concern is, can these techniques help save my life and my family? The rest is bullshit, even though I have legitimate rank from legitimate instructors... Preservation of life, that's it!!!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    February 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    March 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015

    Categories

    All
    Associations
    Business
    Etiquette
    Healing Arts
    History
    Instructor Spotlight
    Interviews
    Martial Arts Principles
    McDojos
    Questions For Our Readers
    Rank
    Self Defense
    Sport Karate
    Weaponry

    Sponsored By

    Picture
    www.TrioMartialArts.com
    Picture
    www.AmericanYoshinkan.com
    Picture
    www.AmericanJidokwan.com
    Picture
    www.RyukyuTe.weebly.com
    Picture
    www.KonteiJudo.com
    Picture
    www.WaeKuneDoKarate.com
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.